Babita Bhardwaj v. North Delhi Municipal Corporation

order on

17.11.2016 mter-se those \ • I contractor!;,and the-fCoiSof^lion%i!llikhus^%,indthe,#parties in the present petitil)nSsi;^J^^ll,^The respondfe^-Soj^orlationwill strictly adhereto thetirnelmexlpf^relia^igg!pay'kf^ petitionerswhichis to the effect that besides the fact that no payment shall be released out of turn to any party, a period of three years and 90 days reckoned from the date the concerned Division has passed the bills of the Contractors for payment shall be the period from which the payment shall start to be made to the contractors. In other words, a cushion of 90 days is agreed to be provided to the Head Quarter/respondent for completing WP(C)Nos. 10055/2015, 10008/2015, 10028/2015, 10032-33/205, 10046/2015, 10051/2016, 10053/2015, 10057-58/2015, 10060/2015, 10064/2015, 11016-17/2015,11025/2015, 11027-28/2015, 11429/2015 11449/2015, 11471/2015. 11531-32/2015, 11737/2015, 11780/2015, 11784-85/2015, 11789/2015, 11792-93/2015, 11796-97/2015, 11799/2015, 11803/2015, 11805/2015, 3891/2016, Page 21 of23 . j.t L. all administrativeworks ofreceivingand diarisingthe bills received from differentDivisionsand preparingthe combinedlist for payment. Up to three years &90 days,, no interestwould be payable by the Departmentto the contractors.However, even if after the expiry of three years, the amounts remain outstanding, the respondent Corporation will pay interest @9% per annum on the principal amountto the contrapt^if&%th^.remaininl|=^p.eriodtillrealization.The Corporatiqn ion @^-'9% princnp|l ^ount to the contractorsshil continue®|l|jf|S^8rperiod of two years reckoned I i , . from theInd ofthe third yek^-asg|i%ipnedin the sub-clpse(vii) and \ I . if this amaunt red^ffi&j%afite''6(5( Corporation,even thereafterthe^fe^fetofe^^Hbe entitled recourse by filing an executionoMg^eriljire-.amoti^^id'lh^orderwill be treated as a decree which would then become executable. The respondent Corporationhas also ensuredthatthe budgetfor realizationofamount underthe head of 'non-plannedexpenditure'will be increasedso that the releaseof paymentto the contractorscan be expeditedin the wait list even prior to the date of prioritymentionedagainsttheir names. fl aforesaid aiTa]f%e^ent^for^pa|M|nt of int'gres.t the respondent WP(C)Nos.10055/2015,10008/2015,10028/2015,10032-33/205,10046/2015,10051/2016,10053/2015, 10057-58/2015, 10060/2015, 1006'l/2015, 11016-17/2015,11025/2015,11027-28/2015, 11429/2015 11446/2015, 11449/2015, 11471/2015, 11531-32/2015, 11737/2015, 11780/2015, 11784-85/2015, 11789/2015, 11792-93/2015, 11796-97/2015, 11799/2015, 11803/2015, 11805/2015, 3891/2016, Page 22 of23 This Court thus notes that the consent order of 17.11.2016reproduced in No.786/2016 is modified to the extent that there being no judgment and decree in favour of the contractorsin the present case; however all other terms and conditions which the respondent (as appellants in the RFA) has agreed and undertakenwill be binding upon them and. this order shall be treated as a decree which in the eventualityof non-pafraeptii ^per_^e%i^s detailed supra) shall 4 • , become executable. ;|i|^f^^i-itby respondentl| Court on this count. [ 'fi 5" t'l ; j )•;, ii.i thus not constrainany parl^^t^;-a^|)'fi^]^the Cour No fukher/ordersare'^lil'M'^ferdMhesfe-,ipe|il;ions^'fheyare disposed of JANUARY 23, 2017 A INDERMEET KAUR, J WP(C)Nos. 10055/2015,10008/2015,'l0028/2^5',10032-33/205,10046/2015,10051/2016,10053/2015', 10057-58/2015, 10060/2015, 10064/2015, 11016-17/2015,11025/2015,11027-28/2015, 11429/201-^' 11446/2015, 11449/2015, 11471/2015, 11531-32/2015, 11737/2015, 11780/2015, 11784-85/2015 11789/2015, 11792-93/2015, 11796-97/2015. 11799/2015, 11803/2015, 11805/2015, 3891/2016' 4035/2016,4061-62/2016,4079/2016.11026/2015 Page23 of-23 ' ' j] !!! p .' l j

v., N * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI 0/^ DateofJudgment:23.01.2017 + W.P.(C)3891/2016 BABITABHARDWAJ Ms.AnusuyaSalwanandMr.Abhishek 22Ki3Bumdir,^dvocates. NORTH / &' € CORAM: HON'BLmMS indermem^EM For orders, s'em|le;%Q|^iF(iC)^ JANUARY 23, 2017 A Goel, Sl^'difi^Counsel for iMC withl^Si&reetBambra, INDERMEET KAUR, J Certify that the digital and physical file have been compared and the digital data is as per the physical file and no page is missing. $-6 to 41, 43 to 47&58 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI % Date ofJudgfnent: 23.01.2017 + W.P.(C) 10055/2015 • , GHWSHYAM DASS Ms.AnusuyaSalwanand Mr.Abhishek ,"s^,4«vssRmmdk,vAdvo cates. M NORTHDE]^lt|uNTCII^i& Goel, Siding Courisel for with Ms.Siifereet Bambfa, 'i ••• vi .Ad-^otate. i; xi & % ri"' f" RAKESHImMAMA^a^"S^^^^-^.;/t. .«. . ... •.^ y .AdVotate. + W.P.(C)^008/2015 petitioner NORTH DELHI MUNICHAL CORPORATION North DMC with Ms.Supreet Bambra, Advocate. + W.P.(C) 10026/2015 MONIKA WP(C)Noe. 10055/2015, 10008/2015, 10028/2015,10032-33/205, 10046/2015, 10051/2016, 10053/2015, 10057-58/2015, 10060/2015, 10064/2015, 11016-17/2015,11025/2015, 11027-28/2015, 11429/2015 11449/2015, 11471/2015, 11531-32/2015, 11737/2015, 11780/2015, 11784-85/2015, 11789/2015, 11792-93/2015, 11796-97/2015. 11799/2015, 11803/2015, ,11805/2015. 3891/2016. 4035/2016, 4061-62/2016,4079/2016, 11026/2015 • Ms.AnusuyaSalwanand Mr.Abhishek NORTHDELHIMUNICIPALCORPORATION North DMC with Ms.SuprretBambra, Advocate. + W.P.(C) 10028/2015 NISHANT i %U T r« ^ Petitionei ,vT^yAniaVi ifCflmATiusuva^lwdkaiidMr.Ab. + W.P.(C)10032/2(1154^^::;^--:^^ • CHIRAC Ms.AnusuyaSalwanand Mr.Abhishek NORTH DELHI MUNICIPALCORPORATION North DMC with Ms.Supreet Bambra, Advocate. WP(C)Nos.10055/2015,10008/2015,10028/2015,10032-33/205,10046/2015,10051/2016,10053/2015, 10057-58/2015, 10060/2015, 10064/2015. 11016-17/2015,11025/2015,11027-28/2015, ,11429/2015 11446/2015, 11449/2015. 11471/2015, 11531-32/2015, 11737/2015, 11780/2015, 11784-85/2015, 11789/2015, 11792-93/2015, 11796-97/2015,11799/2015, 11803/2015, 11805/2015, 3891/2016, Page 2 of23 J .. . J... it,l + W.P.(C) 10033/2015 BRAHAM PRAKASH Ms.Anusuya Salwan and Mr.Abhishek NORTHDELHIMUNICIPALCORPORATION with Ms.Supreet Bambra-,- + ^ r\\ I Ir'-fa W.P.(C)1004^204^'^"^- ,, \ LAXMIN|Ek» '^^A.^^etitioner •f r' ,, '•If ii ^«!v" K'5 I ' Throug^g^;|M&^usuyaSalwanand^Mr.Abhishek I I \\ i. fj I NORTHDELHIIVlSfMIci'^;^ /Respondent ^^ ^G%ej,.<?'S^dingCounsel for Ms.Supreet Bambra, + W.P.(C) 10051/2015 RANBIR SINGH '% V Ms.AnusuyaSalwanand Mr.Abhishek NORTHDELHIMUNICIPALCORPORATION WP(C)Nos. 10055/2015,10008/2015,10028/2015,10032-33/205,10046/2015,10051/2016,10053/2015, 10057-58/2015, 10060/2015, 10064/2015, 11016-17/2015,11025/2015,11027-28/2015, 11429/2015 11446/2015, 11449/2015, 11471/2015, 11531-32/2015, 11737/2015, 11780/2015, 11784-85/2015, 11789/2015, 11792-93/2015, 11796-97/2015, 11799/2015, 11803/2015, 11805/2015, 3891/2016' Page3of23 CC9 North DMC with Ms.Supreet Bambra, Advocate. + W.P.(C) 10053/2015 ANIL KUMAR BHARD WAJ + + Ms.AnusuyaSalwan and Mr.Abhishek NORTH DELHI ^ ^ 0,v% ^ Goel, St^%g Counsel for p^|ffl®)MCwith idstSferretBambra; W.P.(C)|0057/2015 KUSUM flMf versi®'&?t^ § s-Anusuya-e-SMwans^andMr.Abhishek ,A -/£5?I_4/ NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION ..... Respondent North DMC with Ms.Supreet Bambra, Advocate. W.P.(C) 10058/2015 LALITA GARG WP(C)Nos. 10055/2015, 10008/2015, 10028/2015, 10032-33/205, 10046/2015, 10051/2016, 10053/2015, 10057-58/2015, 10060/2015, 10064/2015, 11016-17/2015,11025/2015, 11027-28/2015, 11429/2015 11449/2015, 11471/2015, 11531-32/2015, 11737/2015, 11780/2015, 11784-85/2015, 11789/2015, 11792-93/2015, 11796-97/2015, 11799/2015, 11803/2015, 11805/2015, 3891/2016, 4035/2016,4061-62/2016,4079/2016, 11026/2015 JlUilJiUJJIbJJ.Ii.i.L.:i:LU. .i. Ms.AnusuyaSalwanand Mr.Abhishek NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION Through • Mr.Sunil Goel, Standing Counsel for North DMC with Ms.Supreet Bambra, Advocate. + W.P.(C)10060/2015 _ ANURAGRANA^,,#^^